Reputation How to tell a real reputation management company from a bad one

Nearly every list of the best reputation management companies was written by someone on it, or someone paid to be. We won't publish another one. What helps is knowing which questions get answers that can't be faked, because this category hides pricing, scope and method by default, and the firms worth hiring are the ones that get specific before you've paid anything.

The two answers that should end it

“We have a relationship with Google” and “we can remove that news article.” Nobody has a relationship with Google that removes results, and a true, lawfully published news story doesn't come down. A firm that says either one is describing something it can't do. Assume the rest of the pitch is built the same way.

What we found when we checked

We looked at seven of the largest names in this category and not one of them prints a dollar figure anywhere. Six of the seven return a 404 on their own pricing page, and every route to a number runs through a form or a phone call. That's deliberate design.

Ask what it costs, before anything else

A firm that won't give you a number until it has your phone number is telling you how it sells. Pricing that only exists on a call varies by how worried you sounded, and you can't compare two vendors when neither will put a figure in writing first.

Use a published number as your control. Ours is $2,488, one time, for the standard personal package, and it sits on the pricing page with the scope next to it. Hire us or don't. Either way, one real figure in hand changes every other conversation you have.

Ask what specifically arrives, and get it in writing

“Reputation management” is four different jobs, and a proposal that doesn't say which ones it covers isn't a proposal. Removal, building, outranking and monitoring cost different amounts and take different amounts of time. Lumping them together suits the seller. That's the point. Our breakdown of the four explains why.

Ask for the itemized scope and compare it to one that exists. Ours is written out line by line in the scope guide. That includes what's deliberately not in it.

Ask what happens in month seven

If the answer to a monthly fee is “monitoring and a report,” you're paying four figures a month for something that costs almost nothing to run. The heavy work in this category is front-loaded into the first six weeks, then it tapers, while the retainer invoice stays the same size the whole way.

Ask what the fee becomes once the build is finished. A firm with a good answer has thought about it. Our guide to the retainer model lays out what actually recurs and what doesn't.

Ask who owns the website when you leave

This question catches the most people, and it takes one sentence to ask. If the site they build sits on their domain or their platform, cancelling means losing the asset that was doing the ranking. The monthly fee was never really a service fee.

A website you own is the only surface in the whole engagement nobody can reprice, deplatform or take back. Anything other than a domain in your name means you're renting your own search results.

Ask what they will not be able to do

A firm with no list of things it can't move hasn't looked at your situation. Published news coverage stays. A court opinion stays. Some aggregators suppress rather than delete, and the listing returns, so any honest assessment of a first page comes back with a not-removable pile in it.

We publish the procedures for the removable parts for free, in the guides, with no form in front of them. A firm isn't selling you access to a secret. You're paying it to do the work several hundred times and to notice when something reappears.

Ask what the guarantee actually covers

“Satisfaction guaranteed” isn't a term, it's a mood. A real guarantee names the condition, the window and what you get back. Ours are specific, and they differ by service: Personal information removal carries a thirty-day money-back guarantee with no conditions, with press placements you don't pay if we can't place the story, and Wikipedia work is refunded if the research says you don't qualify.

Ask what happens if the result doesn't move at all. The answer tells you whether the risk sits with them or entirely with you. Listen closely.

Then check the firm the way you would check yourself

Search the company name and read the second page. A reputation firm is the one kind of vendor that should be able to demonstrate the service on itself, and a first page made entirely of its own marketing, with nothing independent on it, is worth noticing either way.

Ask for a case study with numbers in it, not adjectives. Ours are anonymized and carry the figures: six page-one results to zero in three months, nine to zero in six months, one top result gone in eight days. If a firm can't produce proof in that shape, it's asking you to take the outcome on faith.

Hold us to the same list.

Published price, itemized scope, a website you own, and case studies with real numbers in them. Ask us the eight questions and see what comes back.

Have us do it.

See the scope, price, and next steps for the help this guide describes.

See the service

You should have a say in what the internet says about you.

One result may be the immediate problem. If you need help with the wider picture, explore our work for creators, professionals, and justice-impacted people. You can start with one service.

See how we help people manage what comes up online

Explore your options

Every guide we publish is free and ungated. Browse all of them, see what we do and what it costs, or read why we built this company.

Written by Drew Chapin, who ran all of this on his own name first.